Example takeoff from a public bid set. This is a six-sheet renovation of a music stage, workshop and dressing rooms. Its plans are scans with no usable text layer, so every count is made by eye. It is the hardest kind of set for a counter. We counted 55 new devices. A commercial takeoff service counted 54. The drawings come from an open public bid. We leave out the project, owner, city and engineers on purpose.
What this sample shows
- What happens when a PDF has no text to read.
- Fixture types A, B, B-EM, D and P, and the switches.
- Existing high-bay fixtures counted on their own line, outside the new total.
- One extra item in our count, marked medium confidence.
See the sample takeoffs hub for how to read the columns.
The set
| Sheet | Content |
|---|---|
| E-001 | Symbols, abbreviations, drawing list, notes, luminaire schedule |
| E-101 | Demolition and power plans |
| E-102 | Lighting plan and panel schedule |
| E-200, E-201 | Details (not counted) |
| E-300 | Specifications |
Only title-block text could be extracted. The plan geometry is outlines or raster, so the agent rendered each plan in tiles and counted symbols against the legend.
Result: 55 new devices against 54
Test of November 2026: Claude Sonnet with our takeoff instructions, on a PDF it had not seen. The set had not been used to write the instructions.
| Commercial service | Our run | |
|---|---|---|
| E-101 (demolition and power) | 30 | 30 new |
| E-102 (lighting and panel) | 24 | 25 new |
| Total new | 54 | 55 |
| Group | New devices |
|---|---|
| Power | 24 |
| Lighting | 17 |
| Switches & controls | 8 |
| Data, fire alarm, access | 0 |
| Panels & equipment | 6 |
| Total | 55 |
Full line table
Power: 24 new
| Item | Qty | Status | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ceiling OD outlet device box, round (pipe grid, outlet boxes 1101-1108) | 8 | new | high |
| Wall OD outlet device, square PL box (PL 1109, 1110, 1111, 1112) | 4 | new | high |
| Utility box XS-1001 (plain square, 'Box 1001 utility circuit') | 1 | new | medium |
| Duplex receptacle, 20A (ckts 49, 50, 51) | 3 | new | high |
| Duplex receptacle above counter, switched (ckts 44-48) | 5 | new | high |
| Ceiling junction box J (ckt 43, MCC-101S) | 1 | new | high |
| Pull box (cross-hatch symbol) | 1 | new | high |
| Splice box on wall for existing 4#500MCM feeder | 1 | new | low |
Lighting: 17 new
| Item | Qty | Status | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type A 12in recessed LED | 1 | new | high |
| Type B 6in recessed LED downlight | 12 | new | high |
| Type B-EM 6in downlight with battery backup | 2 | new | high |
| Type D wall-mount 20-lamp mirror light | 1 | new | medium |
| Type P pilot light for green room receptacles | 1 | new | medium |
| Type C hi-bay LED (24 existing, relamp only, lamps by others) | 24 | existing | high |
Switches & controls: 8 new
| Item | Qty | Status | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vacancy sensor switch VS | 4 | new | high |
| Single-pole switch $ (workshop) | 1 | new | medium |
| Three-way switch $3 | 2 | new | medium |
| Switch $ for above-counter receptacles and pilot | 1 | new | medium |
Panels & equipment: 6 new
| Item | Qty | Status | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panelboard PB-101S (400A, 120/208V 3PH) | 1 | new | high |
| Motor controller MCC-101S | 1 | new | high |
| Disconnect switch 208V 3P 30A for MCC (note 6) | 1 | new | medium |
| Pipe grid motor connection M | 2 | new | high |
| Equipment rack ER-101S (equipment outlet/connection) | 1 | new | low |
| Existing lighting contactor | 1 | existing | medium |
Where we differ by one
On E-102, the fixtures matched by type: A 1, B 12, B-EM 2, D 1, P 1. The switches matched too: one single-pole switch, two 3-way switches and four vacancy sensor switches. Our run counted one more switch, at the dressing room door. That switch controls the above-counter receptacles and the pilot light. It also appears on E-101. The run counted it once and marked it medium confidence.
We do not know whether the service excluded it or missed it. We did not check it against a hand count, so we cannot say which number is right.
Existing items stay separate
The sound stage has 24 existing high-bay fixtures. They are only relamped. Our run listed them as existing and kept them out of the new total, as did the commercial service. An existing lighting contactor is listed the same way.
What a scan changes
- Without a text layer, there are no tags to count next to the picture. The cross-check with text is gone.
- The panel schedule showed zero load for the lighting circuits, so the wattage cross-check was not possible.
- Receptacle and box circuits could be checked: for example, 24 circuits matched 8 ceiling boxes at 3 circuits each, and 5 plus 3 receptacles matched their panel rows.
- The 24 existing high-bays matched a demolition note that says 24.
Open questions found
- The demolition plan points at the vestibule, but no exit or emergency fixture is drawn there.
- The stage-side 3-way switch appears as an existing switch on the demolition plan and as new on the lighting plan.
- A splice box is drawn only as an oval on the workshop wall. How many?
- Two square boxes have no device description. What type are they, and who supplies them?
- A note says to provide a disconnect for the motor controller, with no fuse size.
- Cable runs are noted for data, but no data outlets are drawn.
- Who relamps the existing fixtures, and who supplies the furniture and theater items?
The commercial service's own question list was not available, so we cannot compare the two lists.
Limits
- There is no hand-verified count of this set.
- One item (the dressing room counter switch) differs from the service, and we did not settle it.
- The commercial service's question list for this set was not available, so we could not compare the lists.
